Well, you can really blame me on this one…
Over the many years, I have spent a considerable amount of time thinking about thinking, beliefs, and the human population in general. Mass human behavior, individual human behavior, politics, wars, religion, art, science, mathematics, networks, complex dynamical systems, and thought contagions.
It occurred to me that, among many other things, that many, many people behave more like mindless automatons than thinking beings. You can see it in advertising, politics, social services, the government in general, and just your average Joe. You see it in fervent believers of religion, the Republican party, the Democratic party, sports, everywhere. You see it in parents, teachers, police, lawyers, social workers, etc.
Basically, most people never — or almost never — bother to critically examine what they believe in. They seem to just jump from one belief frame to another without much thought as to whether or not it even makes sense, let alone if the beliefs themselves are even correct. They are “programmed” by some agent, which could be parents, friends, church leaders, politicians, or the media. They also act on those beliefs, and almost never bother to think about the consequences on acting on unfounded propositions. Even though the consequences are at hand, no learning seems to ever take place to lead them to the very necessary critical analysis of half-baked notions and fuzzy impressions.
But this does not apply to everyone, of course, as there are those who do critically examine notions and assumptions before inculcating the propositions as “beliefs”.
Still others, like myself, eschew the entire mechanism of belief itself. Ask yourself the following question:
Do beliefs determine truth?
I don’t think anyone, not even the Mindless Vessels of Beliefs (MVBs) themselves, would ever answer “yes” to that basic question. And yet the MVBs will go on most likely being MVBs, even after having admitted to the most important flaw in belief systems in general. They may wonder about it a bit and “go back to sleep”. Meanwhile, those who actually DO think already know about the inherent flaws in beliefs in general.
But let’s talk about this very fundamental question. If beliefs do NOT determine truth, then that immediately leads to two more questions:
- Just how DOES one determine truth?
- Just what DOES one do with all of these beliefs?
I will discuss those questions in future blogs. But for now, I want to speak more on beliefs and how people in general measure up.
Sometime after I came up with the idea of MVB, it occurred to me that there are finer layers in how people and beliefs interact. Also, “Mindless Vessel of Belief” sounds kinda harsh, even though I deem 80-90% of the population are MVBs. So I came up with a more general (and gentler) classification system, which I currently call “realms”. And so let me expound on them.
Realm 1: Autonomous Belief Agents
A Mindless Vessel of Belief (MVB) is a person who tends not to question beliefs, but simply acts on them. The “belief matrix”, if you will, drives said person’s activitives from moment to moment. Little, if any, thought is ever given to the “why” behind a belief. When a new proposition is introduced to said person, the new proposition is evaluated solely on the pre-existing belief matrix with little reference to anything substantive. In short, an Autonomous Belief Agent, or MVB, is largely driven by the beliefs themselves rather than knowledge.
I estimate that 80 to 90% of the world operates in this fashion. You get a good sense of this from observing political campaigns, religious organizations, many who operate in the “public sector” for a living where no thought is required, just undue obedience. It’s the type of thing that makes witch-hunts possible, allowed the Holocaust to become a reality, and allowed the United States to “justify” the war with Iraq.
Everywhere you look, from the media to sports to law reeks of this. Any place where people routinely act without rhyme or reason, without any sensibilities, and justify said actions with the excuse of “just doing my job”, etc.
I personally find it quite disturbing and perplexing that most of the world operates in this manner. Many of the often-touted ideals are rendered moot in lieu of the Autonomous Belief Agents, including the notions of “democracy”, “justice”, and “fairness”. The money-driven media, just to stay alive, is forced to kowtow to the MVB, reducing content to the type of drivel and mediocrity that appeals to the common MVB.
Realm 2: Belief Aware
Realm 2 types are somewhat aware and mindful of the nature of beliefs and their pitfalls, but still operate in that context. They do make some efforts at verifying that many of their beliefs are actually knowledge, but still believe(!) that beliefs are either a good thing to have, or at least there’s no way for humans to get around them. They are definitely measure better than your average MVB, but still operate in the context of what they consider “humanity”. Those that fall into this category are liberal arts majors, writers, and poets. Those who are particularly creative typically fall into this realm, as well as many scientists, engineers, and philosophers.
Realm 3: Belief Rejection
Realm 3 types are difficult for me to describe in human terms. Realm 3 speaks about a complete rejection of the entire notion of belief in lieu of Logic and Reason. A Realm 3 person has the ability to “step outside” of humanity and see the human condition for what it really is. A Realm 3 type is totally aware that “beliefs” are merely the backdrop for memes, and that much of what is considered “reality” is a construct of a extremely sophisticated neural process. Even beliefs themselves are a part of that same neural complexity, and as such is suspect.
The reason this is difficult to describe in human terms is because, well, the writer as well as the readers of this article are themselves human, and thus at some level the understanding of Realm 3 become infinitely recursive. For am I not using memetic transfer to convey these concepts to belief organs (your brain) about rejecting what many consider to be the cornerstone of all human existence?
I have not identified anyone other than myself as being in the Realm 3 category. The difficulty lies in distinguishing someone between Realm 3 and Realm 2. Unless the conversation goes directly to the heart of the matter, you would not know if someone who appeared to be Realm 2 is actually Realm 3. Others who fall into this category will most likely have never thought of it in these terms and may feel extremely uncomfortable discussing it with Realm 2 types, let alone Realm 1 people! So, I can give no estimate on what percentage of the population may fall into this category, though I suspect the numbers are very small.
On reflection, I would suspect that those doing research in the field of cognitive psychology would most likely be or on the road to becoming Realm 3 without even realizing it.
Realm 4: Self Rewrite
A person who is a realized Realm 3 is still human, despite the recognition of the fact that the human belief system is itself a construct. But the realization offers the possibility of being able to manipulate one’s own construct. That is to say, you, being a Realm 3 type can now develop the faculties to manipulate your own construction directly. You can, in essence, rewrite your own “programming” This is something I aspire to personally, and have had some limited success at it. It is largely uncharted waters, with new possibilities brimming around every corner. There are also dangers as well, because what happens if you do a bad rewrite unto yourself?
Due to the way our meat brains works, auto-rewriting is very difficult to achieve. What would be ideal is transhumanist approach of replacing or at least augmenting your meat brain with some new technology — Nanotech? Photonics? Quantum Computers? — to allow a much faster means to rewrite and resculpt the self. Such fantastic technology does not exist yet, of course, but it is fun to contemplate.
Realm 5: Peer Rewrite
Realm 5 is not necessarily a “higher” realm than the others — except Realm 1, perhaps. Basically the ability of one human to rewrite another human has been with us throughout the ages. Today, governments of the world do it through control of the school systems and also control of the media. Primal emotions are typically used as the gateways to do peer rewrites, and the primal emotion of choice, I’m afraid to say, is fear. Religious institutions use the fear entry point quite frequently, as well as law enforcement, the IRS, the war propaganda organs, and many others.
Peer Rewrite occurs at all scales of society, including families. Parents by definition (re)write be belief matrices of their offspring, and teachers by definition rewrite their students.
Is Peer Rewrite necessarily a bad thing? In and of itself, no. However, there are a multitude of ethical concerns, as well as much power in being able to rewrite your peers. If it is for reasons of exploitation or control, especially if it is to the detriment of the rewritetee, I consider this a bad thing in general. On the other hand, if a parent is rewriting his kid with the goal in mind of that kid having a happy, healthy and successful life, I would consider that a good thing.
I would consider a rewrite of a Realm 1 (MVB) person to become Realm 2 or better to be a very good thing, as long as it is approached with caution and with recognition that you are, in effect, altering the course of another person’s future, and there may be some unexpected downsides in doing so, if, for instance, said person is unable to handle the realities of reality. The very reason so many may be stuck in Realm 1 in the first play may stem from their inabilities to handle the truth about truth.